Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:woohoo:
 

=GwenavhyeurAnastasia has limited the viewing of this artwork to members of the deviantART community only. You can log in or become a member for FREE!
:icongwenavhyeuranastasia:

Author's Comments

Fin. Had fun. Learned some things about haiku and short poem writing.

---

So, every day I'll be updating this baby with another short poem. It may or may not be a traditional haiku in that its syllable count is 5-7-5.

This is for =Iscariot-Priest's July haiku-thon, which you may read about here. The journal includes a list of participants.

Thoughts and critique requested. You know the drill.

--
1. Many thanks to =Iscariot-Priest and ~SOLARTS for suggestions.
2. Freckles obsession.
3. Cigarettes are gross.
4. Happy Independence Day, America. Traditional 5-7-5 haiku.
5. Looking for books.
6. Piano.
7. Thanks for the call, Daisy.
8. Thinking of painting always makes me miss you.
9. Bo. :heart:
10. How does one fix a wishing well?
11. Words should stay sometimes.
12. Painted my uncle's deck. Got white in my hair and on my jeans. I think white is pretty in red hair.
13. Going down the highway.
14. This morning, once I got home.
15. No se.
16. Time to get dirty.
17. I always wanted to play piano.
18. Too vague? Will exchange for better one.
19. Attempt at tanka. A friend at school's bedroom walls are painted with a map of the world, including all the countries and their capitals. I'm no good when it comes to geography.
20. Don't disturb the reading.
21. Hospitals scare me. But nice opportunity to people watch.
22. Blah. Will exchange for a better one later.
23. I'm hungry.
24. Made proper English and messed with arrangement of lines.
25. I've always wanted to do it. And maybe even get caught.
26. No idea what's going on. Wish mom would call.
27. Not sure on wording or line breaks. Dad came home.
28. I am not going to be the one singing in your mum's phone.
29. Guys are too confusing.
30. Finished my extended essay [draft] on Tolkien's elves. Twenty one words short of the maximum limit.
31. Fin. Listening to 'High Hopes' - Floyd.


Thanks to ~Amertie for help on all.

Critiques


:iconiscariot-priest:
A good start, I like the image - using dawn in your opening piece as well as "sweeping clean", suggesting to start on a clean slate.

Here are two suggestions:

1) "sun rays" sounds odd to me without the possessive noun, perhaps say "sun's rays"

2) the distribution of the words among lines (assuming sun is now a possessive noun):

sun's rays
sweep clean
sheets, morning letters


A few reasons why:

i. as is you've three images: sun rays, clean sheets, letters; and one action "sun rays sweep". This new structure maintains those images and actions.

ii. it makes "sun rays" and "sweep clean" more defined by separating the two into two lines. This allows the image to develop, line by line, rather than run together.

iii. makes full use of "sheets" by linking it to line two and three. A few readings:

a) the sun rays sweep onto the clean sheets (present in both - original and new forms)
b) clean sheets, cluttered by letters (present in both)
c) sheets of unread and forgotten letters (new, as they're now only separated by a comma)
d) the sheets may not be clean, and the sun bright light is making them look clean (new, as now clean and sheets are separated)
e) the sun's also sweeping clean the letters (new, as both are now part of a list, via comma)

iv. Shortens line one and two, "clutters" (lengthens) line three. It better fits the wording, as the sun and its sweeping is neat, while the sheets and letters are not.

Thanks for writing, I hope this was helpful. :)
The Artist thought this was FAIR
19 out of 19 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 1 1 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconblue-pixies:
so far i ish liking very muchly
:heart:

--
i found you
... but lost myself along the way

*project-improve
:iconblue-pixies:
most welcome

--
i found you
... but lost myself along the way

*project-improve
:iconmooshu17:
A question, do the morning letters belong to the sheets? or are the sheets just plural? I got the idea of someone looking at the window at the sheets on the line while writing letters. If that isn't what it is (more or less) do tell :D I like this one a lot, just a little confused.

--
"Happiness is a choice that requires effort at times."
Anonymous
:icongwenavhyeuranastasia:
Oh, ha. Thank you for catching that, it was just meant to be plural sheets, no apostrophe.

It is, more or less, meant to be like that. Someone writing letters with the light of the sun streaming onto their sheets through the window. I also meant it, though, as not necessarily letters that one writes. See, I got the idea whilst reading in bed this morning from the sunlight coming in from my window. So, letters could also mean like letters of the alphabet. Hope that cleared up your confusion some, and again, thank you for pointing out my typo.

--
:boing:
*dALinkSystem | #Writers-Workshop | #project-improve | #LITplease | *Lit-Twitter | =DeviantArtSecret
:boing:
:iconmooshu17:
Ok cool, no problem, I just wanted to see if it was a typo or if you were going for some other angle I just couldn't see.

Wow, I like the second idea too :) Looking forward to see the rest of your stuff :)

--
"Happiness is a choice that requires effort at times."
Anonymous
:icongwenavhyeuranastasia:
Of course, sorry for the confusion, but glad you caught it.

Thank you kindly. =] I can't wait to read more of your work as well.

--
:boing:
*dALinkSystem | #Writers-Workshop | #project-improve | #LITplease | *Lit-Twitter | =DeviantArtSecret
:boing:
:iconmooshu17:
Like I said, not a problem :)

Happy Writing :)

--
"Happiness is a choice that requires effort at times."
Anonymous
:iconmahi-fish:
I look forward to trading haiku with you over the month. :D

Details

July 1
2.6 KB

Statistics

146
27 [who?]
841 (0 today)
10 (0 today)

Site Map